Public consultations in Bath and North East Somerset (B&NES) are increasingly seen as a formality, rather than a real opportunity for residents to influence decisions. Launched during holiday periods and often hard to navigate, these consultations raise serious concerns about the council’s commitment to listening to the public.
One example is the proposed bus gate in Walcot. Despite receiving feedback from 160 local residents, there is little sign their views are being genuinely considered. “It feels like consultations are just a box-ticking exercise,” says local resident Julia Pearson. “We’re asked for feedback, but nothing changes.”
Many consultations are scheduled over Christmas and New Year, leaving little time for people to respond. This lack of consideration for residents’ schedules excludes key groups, particularly working families and vulnerable communities, from participating.
“The timing makes it difficult for working families and vulnerable groups to get involved,” says Leo Harrison, a local Green Party member. “Consultations shouldn’t be scheduled just for convenience they should be accessible and inclusive.”
In Lambridge, over 300 people attended a public meeting, yet decision-makers failed to show up and hear their concerns. This lack of engagement leaves residents frustrated and questioning whether their voices really matter.
In contrast, Manchester’s recent consultation on school travel strategies engaged young people directly, ensuring their voices were heard in decisions that affect their future. This inclusive approach shows what is possible when councils genuinely listen to all members of the community.
Councillor Joanna Wright, Leader of the B&NES Council Green group, said: “Consultations are supposed to be about listening to the public, but too often they are used as a formality rather than a genuine tool for engagement. The current process is failing our communities, and it’s time for B&NES to prioritise inclusivity, accessibility, and meaningful action based on public feedback. Residents deserve a consultation process that truly reflects their views and shapes decisions transparently.”